Obama’s Privacy Proposal: Who’s Game, and Who’s Crying ‘Foul’?

Student privacy is a front and center topic these days. Yesterday, in his January 12th address on American privacy, President Barack Obama highlighted the Student Privacy Pledge, calling for all edtech companies to join in on efforts to protect and use student data responsibly. Already, 75 organizations have signed it, from edtech kingpins like Microsoft and Houghton Mifflin, to startups like ClassDojo and Schoology.

The president also spoke to the need for a nationwide Student Digital Privacy Act, emphasizing the importance of student data privacy for all Americans and sharing that he would propose the legislation by the end of February.  Yet despite big names like Apple (who signed on the eve of POTUS’ speech) adding their John Hancock to the pledge, not everyone is pleased with the directions and efforts that Obama’s speech highlighted. We caught up with a number of organizations and stakeholders–both pledge signers and otherwise–to understand what has them both optimistic and a bit concerned.

Is there a need for federal legislation regarding student data privacy?

Talk to most pledge signers, and you’ll quickly find that the government’s efforts to protect student privacy are seen as an improvement over those of the past. “FERPA was a great start, but it’s time for new, clearer guidelines that address how software is actually used in the classroom today,” says Tyler Bosmeny, CEO of Clever.

While certain states seem proactive (take the landmark student data privacy law passed in 2014 in California as a prime example), it’s difficult for vendors and customers alike to navigate privacy with a mish-mash of different federal and state laws, or as Edmodo CEO Vibhu Mittal calls it, a “patchwork.” He continues: “a clear, well-defined data privacy statute that both protects student privacy and permits technological innovation” to improve education could be helpful, especially “where students and parents are concerned.”

But is new legislation the best way to handle this?

Potential issues and risks

Medbery’s and Chaudhary’s concerns are not to be taken lightly. Other edtech stakeholders also lack of faith in the pledge and potential legislation. A January 13th New York Times article caught up with Rachael Stickland, a mother of two and co-chairwoman of the Parent Coalition for Student Privacy, an organization that launched immediately following the highly-publicized inBloom shutdown.

“Even if the law is passed, parents would still not know which vendors have their kids’ data and what they are doing with it,” Strickland told the New York Times. “There’s this veil of secrecy. Parents would really appreciate that opportunity to know what is going on.”

Shared responsibility for ensuring student data privacy

Though the federal government will ultimately decide what laws will go into place, the majority of education organizations, edtech or otherwise, overwhelmingly agree that the responsibility for ensuring the carrying out of privacy best practices doesn’t fall on the head of any one stakeholder. Districts, for example, can play a role in their responsible selection and implementation of student data systems. Companies can supply clearer privacy policies and educate customers–including parents–about security guidelines and regulations.

However, whether laws need to be put into place to make those best practices happen is up to individual discretion. Where do you stand?

Read the entire article by Mary Jo Madda on edSurge at https://www.edsurge.com/n/2015-01-13-obama-s-privacy-proposal-who-s-game-and-who-s-crying-foul

This entry was posted in Articles/Reports and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Please tell us what you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s